COVID-19: In Times of Crisis Civil Liberties Must be Respected
“Whilst it is true that in a time of emergency it may be justifiable to restrict Civil Liberties temporarily, it is equally true to say that in a time of emergency, we must be very careful to protect our Civil Liberties,” says Michael Cope, QCCL President.
The QCCL condemns the decision of the government yesterday to ram through its health crisis legislation and give itself the power to close down the Parliament.
“Given that the Federal Parliament, with all its logistical difficulties relating to travel, will be able to sit next week for a week, we see no reason why the Queensland government could not have given the Parliament at the very least overnight to consider this legislation” said Mr Cope.
One of the strengths of a pluralistic society is that open debate and criticism of the government can prevent the government from making bad decisions or change the course of bad decisions.
“For this reason, it is entirely inappropriate to shut down debate and close down the Parliament. Again, everyone accepts that steps need to be taken to protect the health and well-being of Members of Parliament and their staff. Given the Federal example, we fail to see how the same thing could not have been done in Queensland”.
The legislation which has been passed, is concerning from the Civil Liberties point of view. Under the legislation, an emergency officer, will be able to order the detention of a person for 14 days in circumstances where there is no:
limit on the number of times that that order may be renewed; or
right of review in a Court; or
need to first see if the person will voluntarily confine themselves.
“If the government wants people to obey these laws, people have to have confidence that they are fair. If there is no right of review, many people may not accept the fairness of the orders.”
“The QCCL accepts that in a time of contagion the government may need powers that trump individual rights. In the context of a contagious disease, the population represents a single biomass and the concept of “the individual” breaks down to a certain extent. But it is important to ensure that our Civil Liberties are protected by making sure that the government does not get powers that are not needed.”
“There appears to be good reason for thinking that this situation may last for at least 18 months. The government needs to take the community with it. Rushing laws through Parliament and closing it down, is not the way to do that.”
For further information contact Michael Cope, President on 07 3223 5939 during office hours and at all times on 0432 847 154